McKinsey and the World Resources Institute. http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Fostering_Effective_Energy_Transition_report_2018.pdf
The newly developed Energy Transition Index (ETI) allows the assessment of 114 countries’ energy systems within this framework, by providing benchmarks across:
- System performance: This measures current performance, based on the delivery of the energy system on the imperatives of the energy triangle, namely promoting an energy system that supports inclusive economic development and growth, secure and reliable access to energy, and environmental sustainability
- Transition readiness: This measures the future preparedness of countries’ systems. Transition readiness is defined using six dimensions, which support effective and timely progress in system performance. They are the
availability of investment and capital, effective regulation and political commitment, stable institutions and governance, supportive infrastructure and an innovative business environment, human capital, and the ability of
the current energy system to accommodate change.
Key findings
There are three major findings from the ETI:
- Over the last five years, more than 80% of countries improved their energy systems, but further effort is needed to resolve the world’s energy-related challenges.
- Current performance and recent improvement in environmental sustainability has been the lowest among the three triangle dimensions. Particle emission levels deteriorated in more than 50% of countries and carbon intensity stayed flat. Energy productivity improved by 1.8% per annum, falling short of the 3% per annum threshold believed to be required to meet the Paris climate change agreement.4
- Security and access remains the area with the biggest gap between highest- and lowest-performing countries. Almost all countries without universal electricity access have seen progress. However, at the global level, the absolute number of people without access still exceeds one billion.5
- Household electricity prices have been rising in real terms since 2013 in more than one-half of countries globally,6 despite an overall fall in primary fuel prices. These developments increase pressures to improve the affordability of energy.
- Countries can foster progress in three ways by establishing favourable conditions for energy system stakeholders, targeting improvement across all three triangle dimensions, and by pursuing improvement levers with synergistic impact across the system.
- The presence of enablers (transition readiness in the ETI) is a strong indicator of the increased performance of countries’ energy systems. The countries with the highest readiness scores are leading the performance ranking. Without these enablers in place, countries’ performance would be average at best. Since transition readiness is multi-dimensional, countries need to establish favorable conditions in all six readiness dimensions to fully capture the opportunities from the energy transition.
- Countries that have not pursued a balanced approach to improve the energy triangle across its three imperatives showed below-average performance improvements. On the other hand, countries that managed to develop high performance levels show more balanced improvement across the three dimensions.
- Removal of fossil fuel subsidies and the reduction of energy intensity are important improvement levers as they showed synergistic impact on other dimensions of the energy triangle. Countries making progress in these two dimensions showed proportionately greater improvement in the other dimensions across the energy triangle.
- Countries follow different transition paths and need to develop country-specific roadmaps. Comparative analysis among peers can highlight opportunities for improvement.
- Countries with high performance and most enablers in place have led the improvement in environmental sustainability, while countries with relatively low performance or readiness narrowed the gap in security and access, and economic development and growth.
- Countries are encouraged to benchmark themselves against comparable peer groups (e.g. geographies, development status, energy trade balance) to identify good practice examples and develop suitable improvement levers, applicable to their circumstances.
- Energy importing economies showed higher transition readiness levels and benefitted more from the lower energy prices of the last five years. Out of these countries, some of those with lower performance levels (e.g. People’s Republic of China or Kenya) established a working ecosystem of enablers, including strong regulations, infrastructure and an innovative business environment, which helped them attract investment for future improvements.
Moving forward
The ETI can serve as a tool to track countries’ performance and readiness as well as to identify energy systems’ strengths and improvement areas, business opportunities and threats. In addition to global benchmarking, peer
comparisons against countries with similar structural backgrounds and starting positions, it enables identification of relevant reference points. It also supports the development of a vision of energy transition, and ultimately,
a roadmap. Such a country roadmap needs to take into consideration that energy transition does not happen overnight and there are high levels of uncertainty in the energy sector (e.g. the pace of technology development,
price volatility etc.). Reflecting this, after developing a plan, countries must remain flexible in an everchanging environment.
Previous country-specific energy transition work shows the complexity of the task ahead as well as the benefits that such transition roadmaps can offer. All stakeholders – and policy-makers in particular – are encouraged to use longterm value for a country as the main criterion to optimize a transition roadmap, develop specific plans for each demand sector and align incentives with the longer-term perspective. The Forum aims to support country-level transition efforts in two ways. It provides transparency on countries’ progress, which is achieved by publishing the ETI on a regular basis. The Forum functions as catalyst, facilitator and a platform, all of which are designed to create stakeholder engagement across the energy system and foster the exchange of good practice globally.
