Chicago implements energy rating system for buildings + affordable, ZNE Habitat homes in Colorado

Credit: Pedro Szekely

Katie Pyzyk, Smart Cities Dive, Aug. 26, 2019

  • Chicago launched its Energy Rating System to rate and make public the energy efficiency of large buildings (50,000 square feet or larger), including about 3,400 buildings across the city. 
  • The buildings will be provided with placards illustrating their energy performance on a zero to four-star scale, which they are required to display on-site and report at the time of building sale or lease. The city will list the ratings on the Chicago Data Portal after an initial six-month grace period for buildings to post the placards.
  • The goal of the program is to increase awareness and encourage energy efficiency by making the information about energy performance more transparent and easier to understand, Amy Jewel, Senior City Advisor, City Energy Project, told Smart Cities Dive via email.
Credit: City of Chicago 

The Energy Rating System was established by the City Council via ordinance in 2017 and just now is being implemented.

Each rating will be based on the energy benchmarking reports that buildings are already required to submit annually to be in compliance with the Chicago Energy Benchmarking Ordinance, passed in 2013. The software used to report the data to the city also provides analysis of buildings’ energy performance, including a 1 to 100 Energy Star score. The city assigns the new ratings for each building based on the Energy Star score.

Energy Star scores are not available for about 10-15% of buildings, and in those cases the city bases ratings on energy use per square foot, Jewel explained. The Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection has authority over compliance and in the past has cited building owners that did not submit their reports.

Building owners can, but are not required to, take actions to improve their ratings each year. The owners are encouraged to dig deeper into their energy benchmarking data to find areas that could be improved and to participate in various energy efficiency improvement programs.

The city mailed the first batch of 11×17 inch placards last week and the rest will be finalized and mailed by mid-September. New placards will be issued each year. Although building owners currently have a six-month grace period to post the placards as the program kicks off, they will have to post new placards immediately upon receipt each year. 

Earlier this year, Chicago committed to using 100% renewable energy citywide by 2035. Targeting buildings for energy reduction is a key part of the city’s strategies to increase energy efficiency and improve environmental friendliness. Large buildings are one of the most significant contributors to greenhouse gas emissions. Chicago estimates buildings account for about 72% of the city’s greenhouse gas emissions.

“Buildings that are energy efficient are the best candidates for renewable energy, since those buildings use less energy overall and thus the renewable energy becomes more feasible,” Jewel said.

The renewable energy resolution also includes the goal of transitioning to a complete electrification of the Chicago Transit Authority’s bus fleet by 2040. In addition, Chicago has committed to reach goals included in the Paris agreement: 26-28% reduction of emissions by 2025. 

Chicago touts itself as the first U.S. city to have a large building energy rating requirement via the Energy Rating System. But even other cities that do not yet have a requirement for displaying ratings or reporting energy efficiency data are working toward building benchmarking.

Pittsburgh released its first energy benchmarking report earlier this month for municipal buildings owned and operated by the city. The city will track annual progress on the effects of implementing energy saving projects on overall energy and emissions reductions, as well as creating accountability for the city’s actions. 

An Affordable, Net-Zero, All-Electric Community in the Colorado Rockies

May 28, 2019  |  By Laurie Stone

Last week the Rocky Mountain Institute Basalt office (and two of our Boulder colleagues) had an amazing opportunity. We were able to volunteer to help build houses with Habitat for Humanity. But these weren’t just regular houses. These are in the first affordable, net-zero, and all-electric housing project in Western Colorado. The 27 homes in the Basalt Vista Affordable Housing Community will not only be affordable to buy, thanks to myriad partners that are donating and subsidizing the cost of many elements (see sidebar “A Community Partnership Helped Make the Homes Affordable”), but also affordable to operate because they will generate more energy than they use.

A Community Partnership

When Habitat went to the town of Basalt to get approvals for an affordable housing project, one of the town council members happened to be Auden Schendler, vice president of sustainability for Aspen Skiing Company and a former RMI employee. Schendler requested that they forgo installing a gas line and go all-electric and even make it net zero. That’s when a local nonprofit, the Community Office for Resource Efficiency (CORE), got involved to help with the net-zero energy aspect. “After experiencing the Innovation Center at Rocky Mountain Institute, it became clear to me that we were at a crossroads on energy efficient buildings in this climate,” said CORE Program Director Marty Treadway. “When the Basalt Vista project came to us, it was really CORE’s first opportunity to apply these net-zero energy concepts to an entire neighborhood.”

While the local Habitat chapter has been building efficient homes and installing solar photovoltaics on them for some time, they had never tackled an entirely net-zero housing development. They had already started to put in the fossil fuel infrastructure, and had only 45 days to make a decision about trying to go net zero before they had to decide if they needed to put in a gas line. According to Amy French, volunteer coordinator for Habitat, “Looking at all of the energy performance data and doing a cost analysis, we decided that it was the right thing to do, and that we could then show other affordable building projects that they could move in this direction as well.” And not bringing in gas infrastructure saved them $30,000 plus additional significant costs to bring gas to each individual home.

Why All-Electric?

There are two good reasons for houses to be all-electric: the health of the home’s residents and the health of the planet. The 70 million homes and businesses in the United States that burn natural gas, oil, or propane for heating, cooking, drying clothes, and more generate 560 million tons of carbon dioxide each year. What’s more, the entire gas distribution system leaks methane, which is 80 times more polluting than carbon dioxide over a 20-year period. Overall, the use of these fuels in our buildings is responsible for upward of a billion tons of annual CO2-equivalent emissions—or 15–20 percent of total US emissions.

There are two good reasons for houses to be all-electric: the health of the home’s residents and the health of the planet.

And gas stoves emit pollutants—like nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide—into our homes, leading to asthma and other ailments. “When you are cooking, those invisible pollutants can easily reach levels that would be illegal outdoors,” says RMI Managing Director Bruce Nilles. “But the Clean Air Act does not regulate the air inside our homes.”

Not only is it safer and healthier to go all-electric, but the time is right. New technologies such as heat pumps and induction stoves are extremely efficient. And with the price of renewable energy falling, we can affordably run our appliances on clean energy.

And that’s exactly what Habitat for Humanity is doing in Basalt Vista. The two- to four-bedroom units will each have a solar photovoltaic system on the roof averaging 11 kW. They will be equipped with heat pumps (which use electricity to move heat from a cool space to a warm space, both for hot water and space heating and cooling), induction stoves (which use magnetic waves to heat up pots), electric vehicle charging stations, LED lighting, and EnergyStar-rated appliances.

The residents will all receive training and a homeowner’s manual that will explain how to interact with the unfamiliar appliances and equipment and provide other information that first-time homeowners might need, such as tips on saving money for emergencies. But the manual goes beyond just being a basic guide to the house. According to Bo Blodgett, Habitat programs coordinator and analyst, who is writing the manual, “The manual will have a behavioral aspect as well. We want people to realize that they are part of the net-zero system, instead of just thinking about how the system can work for them—or working against it outright.”

A Live Learning Lab

One of the most exciting aspects of the project is the partnership with the local utility, Holy Cross Energy (HCE), a cooperative utility with more than 46,000 members. HCE is using the housing development as a learning lab, with the aim to show how adjusting energy levels provided by solar photovoltaics and batteries can both save money for customers and benefit the grid. HCE is installing smart controllers and battery banks in four of the homes for a four-month test period (it is hoping to extend it to a 10-month period). These controllers will allow HCE to manage members’ loads or pull energy from the battery or solar system.

There are basically three different modes that the system can operate in. The energy-saving mode will use algorithms based on the customer’s habits. “If you take a shower at the same time each morning, give or take 15 minutes, the water heater shouldn’t have to keeping your water hot at all hours of the day,” said Chris Bilby, a research engineer with Holy Cross Energy.

The customer mode will work to reduce the customer’s bill. Through smart appliances, HCE can reduce the amount of energy customers need to pull from the grid during peak demand when rates are highest. Any adjustments that HCE makes would go unnoticed by homeowners.

And the peak load management mode will actually be able to pull energy into the grid from the batteries or directly from the solar system when the grid needs it and the home doesn’t.

All of the data from the four homes over the test period will be utilized by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory to validate its efficiency models for the units to see if this model can be replicated in communities around the country. “This is a very exciting project for Holy Cross because it will provide the framework for dispatching and controlling distributed energy resources, and it helps Holy Cross understand the benefits of distribution flexibility as a grid service,” said Bilby. “This approach will allow HCE to invest in new renewable energy projects, build a more flexible and resilient distribution grid, and provide new energy products and services to our members.”

Affordable Green Living

Thanks to a lot of community support (see sidebar), the homes will cost less than half the price of an average home in the area. They are slated for teachers and other low-income families. And not only will the families have an affordable mortgage, they will also have little to no utility costs. “Having low utility costs will help families succeed in the long term. In many affordable housing projects, people still have to pay full market value for energy costs and maintenance. A net-zero home sets them up for further success as a homeowner,” says French.

RMI was excited that we got to be a small part of this exciting development, and that our gas-free net-zero energy office building is helping to spur other developments that are tackling climate change and making a difference.