Associated Press, June 22, 2020
A contractor for the Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. collects a water sample from a resident’s home in Dimock, Pa. on Feb. 13, 2012 (Photo: Associated Press)
A court could finally determine if well water pollution in Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania’s, fracking Ground Zero is naturally occurring or the result of bad practices by Cabot Oil & Gas Corp.
The issue has been contentious since fracking first began in Pennsylvania’s Northern Tier more than a decade ago. But now, Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro has taken up the residents’ cause, alleging Cabot’s drilling mistakes fouled the water for several residents in the rural community of Dimock.
Not us, contends Cabot, which intends to fight charges brought by Shapiro, who, in a lawsuit, claims the Houston-based company failed to fix faulty gas wells that are leaking methane into residential water supplies. Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. was charged on June 15 following a grand jury investigation.
The company said it “categorically denies” assertions that it “acted with indifference toward the community where we live and operate.” A Cabot statement said its “history and involvement in the community shows a very different reality than what was painted” by the grand jury.
The Pennsylvania attorney general’s office filed 15 criminal charges against Cabot, nine of them felonies. Cabot has not yet entered a plea. A preliminary hearing has been scheduled for July 21.
Friction goes way back: Gas driller Cabot backs off demand to have Susquehanna County man thrown in jail
Long fight: Fracking’s impact on groundwater lingers in northern Pennsylvania
NY’s fracking legacy: With the death of fracking, can renewables fill New York’s energy gap?
Fracking politics: Fact Check: Joe Biden wants to eliminate new fracking permits, not all fracking
The company has racked up hundreds of civil violations since 2007, and it has been banned from drilling in a nine-square-mile area of Dimock.
“We find that, over a period of many years, and despite mounting evidence, Cabot Oil & Gas failed to acknowledge and correct conduct that polluted Pennsylvania water through stray gas migration,” the grand jury wrote, criticizing Cabot’s “long-term indifference to the damage it caused to the environment and citizens of Susquehanna County.”
The Pennsylvania attorney general’s office charged Cabot with a total of 15 criminal counts, including illegal discharge of industrial wastes and unlawful conduct under the state’s Clean Streams Law. Maximum fines are $50,000 or $25,000, depending on the count.
“Cabot took shortcuts that broke the law, damaged our environment, harming our water supplies and endangering Pennsylvanians. They put their bottom line ahead of the health and safety of our neighbors,” Shapiro said in a video statement.
A Cabot Oil & Gas Corp. wellhead in Dimock, Pa. (Photo: AP)
The company has long insisted the gas in Dimock’s aquifer is naturally occurring, saying its pre-drill testing of thousands of private water wells in the area show a high percentage with methane. The grand jury asserted that Cabot’s initial sampling of wells and groundwater did not include tests for methane. State environmental regulators eventually determined that Cabot’s drilling and fracking operations leaked explosive levels of methane into private water supplies.
It was an exploding water well on New Year’s Day 2009 that first aroused public attention in Dimock, a patchwork of homes and farms.
Residents said they suffered ill health effects from the contamination of their water with methane and drilling chemicals, including nausea, dizziness, skin rashes, impaired vision and breathing difficulties. Property values plummeted, too, they said.
Methane is not known to be harmful to ingest, but at high concentrations, it’s flammable and, if it escapes into enclosed areas, can cause asphyxiation.
Homeowners sued and later settled with the company.
One resident, Eric Roos, told the grand jury in 2019 that he wants to move, but can’t. “I don’t know who will buy my house now. How can I leave?” he said, according to the grand jury’s report.
Dimock resident Ray Kemble, who has long publicly denounced Cabot and is currently battling it in court, welcomed the news that it faces criminal charges.
“I’m ecstatic, man. I feel vindicated now,” he told The Associated Press. Kemble, who says his water supply was ruined by Cabot, said he wants the company shut down.
The contamination in Dimock became the subject of fierce debate among pro- and anti-drilling forces. An Emmy award-winning 2010 documentary, “Gasland,” showed residents lighting their tap water on fire. Drilling supporters have long accused Dimock residents of seeking money and attention.
The criminal charges against Cabot stem from a two-year grand jury investigation into Pennsylvania’s huge Marcellus Shale gas industry. Last week, Shapiro’s office announced a deal with another company, Range Resources Corp., Pennsylvania’s most active shale gas driller, to plead no contest to environmental crimes over its handling of contamination at a pair of well sites in the southwestern part of the state.
Shapiro said Monday that the grand jury’s ongoing probe “will result in more criminal charges.”
Unlike Range, he said, Cabot “continues to abdicate their responsibility.”
“Cabot knows what they’ve done. The residents of the commonwealth whose lives have been impacted know what Cabot has done. The game that Cabot continues to play, risking the lives of people across the commonwealth for a profit, well, that cannot go on any longer,” he said.