Breaking with the Defunct Idea of Development: Re-embedding the economy in people and the biosphere,

By Daniel McCurdy, Alliance for Global Justice. October 3, 2020 | CREATE! A longer version of this article was included in the book “The Revolution Won’t Be Stopped: Nicaragua Advances Despite US Unconventional Warfare” published by the AfGJ. Go to p. 123.

One of the particularities of tourism in Nicaragua is its democratization. Since the Sandinista government won elections in 2006 and came to power in 2007, the promotion and expansion of the tourism sector is increasingly important for Nicaraguans, contributing significantly to a rise in incomes for many lower-income families.[i] Contrary to the focus on tourism (or even ‘ecotourism) for export in many countries, the Nicaraguan government’s tourism policies incentivize Nicaraguan working-class family tourism. This has been the result not only of tourism promotion outside of the country, but primarily a consequence of the Nicaraguan government’s social, economic and legal policies directed towards re-embedding the economy in the biosphere and in Nicaraguans.

As Anasha Campbell, Nicaragua’s Tourism Minister points out, “in Nicaragua, tourism is based on small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Eighty percent of the tourism industry is based on SMEs and the democratization of government investments means that benefits go directly to the Nicaraguan people. They do not go to big capital, which mostly exports the benefits of this sector.” While multinational corporations and big business do exist in Nicaragua, they do not dominate the economy. The fact that SMEs are at the heart of the tourism economy means that “the Nicaraguan people and Nicaraguan families are the ones who offer their services and products in the tourism industry.” [ii]

Most goods and services related to tourism, like many other income-generating and life-sustaining activities in Nicaragua, come from what Nicaraguan sociologist Orlando Nuñez Soto calls “the popular economy” (or “the people’s economy”). This “economic subject” is formally “composed of the family, community, cooperative and associative sector and is organized into the Council for Social Economy (CES), where low-income farmers, peasants, fishermen, artisans and merchants are grouped together.” The popular economy, as Nuñez points out, produces more than fifty percent of the wealth in Nicaragua in terms of income (big business produces around thirty percent while the public sector produces fourteen percent).[iii] Considering government policy in general, and tourism policies specifically, one can observe that it is precisely the popular economy that is at the center of the Sandinista government’s priorities.

Tourism Minister Campbell, one of a majority of women who head Nicaraguan government ministries, emphasizes that, “For us, tourism is seen as a strategy for the human development of the Nicaraguan people. From 2015 until now tourism has been the main income generating sector for the Nicaraguan economy in general. That means work for the Nicaraguan people, but it also means that the people of Nicaragua have seen the sector as a means to generate their income; both to develop their families and to develop their own community.[iv]

Tourism Policy, The Biosphere And Nicaraguan Culture(S)

Nicaraguan government tourism policy[v] has specifically focused on being coherent with orienting resources and plans in order to integrate the concept of equity with the biosphere and Nicaraguan culture(s). The pillars of the strategy are the following:

  • Develop tourism activity based on national identity, integrating the very lives of Nicaraguans, (their way of being, idiosyncrasies, culture, traditions, religiosity, gastronomy, history and national heritage) within national and international tourism.
  • Integrate productive activities, like agriculture and the Family and Community Economy, into tourism networks.
  • Link tourism activities and networks with small businesses and productive enterprises.
  • Promote and develop National Tourism in order to strengthen Nicaraguan identity and pride by integrating with tourism the knowledge and identification of culture, values, traditions and attractions of the different regions and departments of the country.
  • Incorporate tourism in all sectors; public, large, medium, small and micro private enterprises, and family and community economy.
  • Encourage shared responsibility in tourism management between the different types of users.
  • Promote a special role for the people, Nicaraguan families and communities within tourist activity, as part of its attractiveness.
  • Promote training for all participants in tourism as a mechanism to improve the quality, care and responsibility with which to provide tourism services and complementary activities.
  • Promote the Nicaraguan values that permit the evolution of a responsible tourism that encourages respect and places people, families, women and children and the environment at that center.
  • Promote investments that improve conditions and infrastructure not just with tourism in mind but also the rights and desires of Nicaraguan people.

Notwithstanding the contradictions of implementing change in a predominantly capitalist world, Nicaraguan government initiatives have attempted to push back against the governing economic world-view, asserting its sovereign right to act according to values of culture, democracy and justice as perceived by Nicaraguans and in the Nicaraguan context – not Western-imposed interpretations.

Tourism (both international and domestic) has also allowed for a renewal in the relationship between the Pacific and the Caribbean (Atlantic) Coasts of Nicaragua. For the majority of Nicaragua’s history, the Atlantic Coast was marginalized from the rest of the country. However, the Sandinista government has focused on rehabilitating the relationship between both parts of the country. As a result of improvements in infrastructure, health and education on the Atlantic Coast, tourism policy also promotes the experience of, as Campbell puts it, “a different part of Nicaraguan history; how to interact with the different cultures.” Campbell says that she, herself, is part of the policy of diversity and peace:

“I am one of those examples. I am from Bluefields (on the Atlantic Coast) and this democratization of tourism brings it together, brings that ease of interaction between Nicaraguans, between the Pacific coast of Nicaragua and the Caribbean coast of Nicaragua…that in itself is how tourism has been providing benefits to all the different parts of society, helping to bring about understanding among the people, encompassing that multicultural and multiethnic part of the nation in general. Therefore, we believe, not only in terms of employment or income generation, that tourism enhances that understanding between cultures and also contributes to strengthening the culture of peace in all countries. Nicaragua is no exception.”

Between 2007 and 2018, tourism policy in Nicaragua served as an example around the world.[vi] In addition to being the second fastest growing destination in the entire American continent (eighth in the world), Nicaragua was also classified as one of the safest countries to visit in Central America, second in Latin America. Security and tourism attractiveness, however, should not be looked at in a vacuum. These are the results of a comprehensive governmental effort to bring a sense of dignity back to the people through free health care and education, access to electricity and water, roads, food-sovereignty and more.

2018 Coup Attempt And Tourism

But the government of Nicaragua was, unfortunately (in the eyes of Western capitalism and “democracy”) not going in the right direction with these policies.[vii] The Nicaraguan capitalist conservative sectors and the oligarchy, in coordination with the US government, could not stand the continued success of a government that was not directly controlled by their interests. As Kevin Zeese and Nils McCune put it in their article Correcting the record: What is really happening in Nicaragua, the problem is “the example Nicaragua has set for a successful social and economic model outside the US sphere of domination.”[viii]

Nicaraguan tourism policies aren’t necessarily a ‘problem’ for the US government in of themselves, as much as the fact that they successfully attracted foreign (i.e. US) tourists to visit the country. If there is a threat of successful “tourism” in Nicaragua, it is that Nicaragua, a country with few resources compared to wealthy countries like the US, could improve so much in terms of general human social, economic and health well-being.[ix]

The United States’ long-term regime change efforts in Nicaragua culminated in an attempted coup that saw the tourism sector come to nearly a full stop in mid 2018.[x] The main initial objectives of the “soft” coup-attempt were to discredit Nicaraguan government policies and delegitimize the president, Daniel Ortega, in the hopes of imposing a new government more favorable to US and oligarchical interests.

However, in the months after the 2018 coup-attempt failed, and despite a relentless and continued barrage of fake news – not only in Nicaraguan-opposition and international media outlets but also on official US and European foreign ministry websites – regarding the situation, tourism slowly started returning to Nicaragua.

Challenges To A Different Future In Tourism: Development, Capitalism And Path-Dependency

Since its formative years as a state, Nicaragua has played a small but revelatory role in the global economy of resource extraction and capital circulation. The European discovery of ‘America’ and the industrial revolution made Nicaragua’s geographical location and landscape greatly susceptible to the demands of international commerce and, as a result, US hemispheric commercial interest.

From coffee, cattle and cotton to mining and cheap labor, the demands of the global trade in goods (and labor) have shaped Nicaragua’s landscape. Successive US-imposed Nicaraguan governments deepened the entrenchment of Nicaragua’s economy, culture, and politics into the global order of capital circulation. In 1979, however, the Sandinista Revolution put this trajectory of traditional development and growth into question.

To break from this trajectory is extremely difficult and complicated. From Sandinista government policies in the 1980’s to its policies during the last fourteen years, the most significant challenge to creating an alternative to ‘development’ has been to overcome the combination of long-term US government intervention and the chains of “path dependency”, imposed by political, legal, socio-economic and psychological local and international structures. For Nicaragua to break away from the path chartered by global capitalism means confronting the traditional paradigms of development and growth, a transformation that is not as easy as “dandole vuelta a una tortilla” (Nicaraguan saying; literally meaning “flipping a tortilla;” metaphorically meaning changing a situation quickly).

Presently, international tourism is vital for Nicaragua, as are other export goods, since it not only allows people from around the world to discover “the land of lakes and volcanoes,” but, thanks to government policy, it provides Nicaraguans with the possibility of a dignified means of income that does not directly over-exploit humans and the environment. However, given that tourism, as all other export-revenue (dollar) generating activities, is inevitably part of the global metabolism of capitalism, the challenge for Nicaragua in the future will be to decrease its dependency on the double-sided coin of foreign exchange and export activities.

This is not an easy task because it means transforming how and what people consume. It means transforming not only what Nicaraguans consume – most Nicaraguans already consume very locally, except for the middle and upper classes – but also what tourists consume. This doesn’t mean cutting Nicaragua off from the world, but finding a balance that is favorable to Nicaraguans in times of instability. It means creating a new tourism that is low-carbon, circular, complimentary, respectful of people and the environment.

In his latest book, Paul Oquist, Minister and Private Secretary for National Policies for the Presidency of Nicaragua, remarks that “the hegemonic economic, social, and political structures, as well as mechanization, automation and artificial intelligence have concentrated wealth to the point where one percent of the world’s population controls over fifty percent of the world’s wealth. At the same time wealth redistribution mechanisms have been weakened. If this continues with the imminent rapid expansion of artificial intelligence, nearly worldwide economic, social, labor, and political instability and crises are completely predictable.”[xi]

Oquist and the Nicaraguan government are very conscious of the situation Nicaragua faces in light of global challenges. In writing about the dominant forms of development, Oquist says “we have lost touch with our place in the evolution of the universe and Mother Earth. Our most common answers to the big questions have worn thin and lack the spiritual urgency that can be the basis for a Survival Movement. For this we need to have an understanding of the Universe and Mother Earth and how we are an integral part of evolution, collectively and individually, that renews our identity and values, and elevates our level of consciousness of our current situation and the vulnerabilities and risks that threaten our existence. What is required is a transformation through a Survival Social Movement that constructs a low-carbon, climate-resistant and resilient, circular, sustainable society with far greater equality.”

In effect, Nicaraguan government (tourism) policies are rooted in the spirit of a “Survival Social Movement” seeking to discover, through real world practice, other ways of living fulfilling lives as individuals, families and communities, all this while facing enormous internal and external contradictions and pressures to succumb to the imperial God of development.

Footnotes:

[i] Di Fabio, Luca. “Economic Growth in Nicaragua Has Helped Reduce Poverty,” April 30, 2018. https://borgenproject.org/economic-growth-in-nicaragua-helped-reduce-poverty/.

[ii]  “Turismo, Democracia y Desarrollo En Nicaragua.” 19 Digital, August 26, 2018. https://www.el19digital.com/articulos/ver/titulo:80715-turismo-democracia-y-desarrollo-en-nicaragua.

[iii] Nuñez Soto, Orlando, and César Martínez. “Who Produces the Wealth in Nicaragua?” Tortilla Con Sal, 2018. http://www.tortillaconsal.com/tortilla/node/7155.

[iv] “Turismo, Democracia y Desarrollo En Nicaragua.” 19 Digital, August 26, 2018.

[v]  “Nicaragua, Crezcamos Juntos!: Políticas y Proyectos de Desarrollo Para Potenciar la Inversión 2017-2021.” ProNicaragua, 2016.https://www.el19digital.com/app/webroot/tinymce/source/2016/00-AGOSTO/Politicas_y_Proyectos_Nacionales.pdf.

[vi] Sayles, Jill. “Nicaragua Announces Commitment to Sustainability.” Travel Daily Media, 2017. https://www.traveldailymedia.com/nicaragua-announces-commitment-sustainability/, and also

“Tourism Booming in Nicaragua,” January 12, 2018. http://www.nicaraguasc.org.uk/news/article/273/Tourism-booming-in-Nicaragua.

[vii] S. Wilson, Brian and Nils McCune. “US Imperialism and Nicaragua: ‘They Would Not Let Our Flower Blossom.’” In Live from Nicaragua: Uprising or Coup? A Reader. Alliance for Global Justice, 2019.

[viii] Zeese, Kevin, and Nils McCune. “Correcting the Record: What Is Really Happening in Nicaragua?,” July 11, 2018. https://www.globalresearch.ca/correcting-the-record-what-is-really-happening-in-nicaragua/5647092.

[ix] McCurdy, Daniel. “Nicaragua: Improvements in Social and Economic Well-Being and the Nov. 6 Elections.” Center for Economic and Policy Research, November, 2011. https://cepr.net/nicaragua-improvements-in-social-and-economic-well-being-and-the-nov-6-elections/.

[x] Live from Nicaragua: Uprising or Coup? A Reader. Alliance for Global Justice, 2019.

[xi] Oquist, Paul. Equilibra: The Philosophy and Political Economy of Existence and Extinction, 2020. https://read.amazon.com/kp/kshare?asin=B087DYQCX9&id=iII_FBbCSDyIMC28j6vCnw&reshareId=BAF3C493KZYQZTJ2QHNY&reshareChannel=system.

The Revolution Won’t Be Stopped: Nicaragua Advances Despite US Unconventional Warfare

July 15, 2020

The book is edited by Nan McCurdy and written by a collective of historians, researchers and activists committed to finding and sharing the truth about US intervention in Nicaragua.

2019 was an amazing year in the search for peace in Nicaragua with The Amnesty Law and promotion of reconciliation between neighbors in every corner of the nation. It was a year of life-giving advances in all aspects of wellbeing: poverty reduction, health, education, gender equity, recreation, culture and infrastructure; strengthened food security, and a new highway that joins Bluefields to the rest of the nation making the first paved transit route from the Caribbean to the Pacific.

And all this despite cruel US unconventional warfare against the Sandinistas that has gone on for decades and reached a peak in April 2018. 2019 was a year of rebuilding lives as well as the economy after the 2018 violence.

As if that wasn’t a big enough challenge, in the afterword we cover the excellent government handling of Covid-19 and how the virus has been used as a weapon to attack the Sandinista government with a narrative full of lies and falsities in the corporate press and social media.

Nicaragua continues to be a “threat of a good example” that other countries will follow. After our 2019 e-book about 2018, “Live from Nicaragua,” our 2020 e-book “The Revolution Won’t be Stopped” brings the story up to date.

Download in English and Spanish, in a pdf or E-reader format below. For newcomers, downloading PDFs is fast, safe and easy. Then you can read the book free on your computer, phone or other device. Here are the links:

Icon

The Revolution Won’t Be Stopped: Nicaragua Advances Despite US Unconventional Warfare

 1 file(s)  3.13 MBDOWNLOAD

Icon

La Revolucion No Se Detendra

 1 file(s)  3.31 MBDOWNLOAD

Icon

The Revolution Won’t Be Stopped .Mobi

 1 file(s)  2.85 MBDOWNLOAD

Icon

The Revolution Won’t be Stopped Ebook

 1 file(s)  3.22 MB DOWNLOAD

If you would like to donate in honor of this new book, please use the following link to the newly created Nicaragua Solidarity Fund “Padre Miguel d’Escoto Brockman.”  Funds will go to help efforts to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.  Because of US sanctions, it is not possible for Nicaragua to access funding available to other countries from the World Bank, the Inter-American Development Bank and the IMF.  The Nicaragua Solidarity Fund was recently established via the Alliance for Global Justice (AfGJ) to serve as a people´s reparations fund to the people of Nicaragua given that the United States government refused to accept and comply with the ruling of the International Court of Justice of 1986.   The ICJ ruled in favor of Nicaragua and against the United States, awarding reparations to Nicaragua. The US continues to violate international Law by placing sanctions against Nicaragua. These sanctions are preventing Nicaragua from accessing new concessional loans, grants or debt relief from multilateral sources. The Nicaragua Solidarity Fund will be managed by a collective of people in Nicaragua and the US in coordination with the AFGJ.  Donations made in 2020 will be used to help Nicaraguans deal with the ongoing Covid-19 crisis by supporting the purchase of medicines, personal protection equipment or other needs identified by the Nicaragua government and especially the Nicaragua Ministry of Health.

Briefs

By Nan McCurdy

40 Cents of Every Dollar for Health and Education
The Minister of Finance and Public Credit Iván Acosta said on July 7 that, despite the situation of the pandemic, no project has been stopped. “We believe that for our people, it is good news that the government is making its contribution to keep the country on its feet and progressing,” Acosta said.  Budget execution for the first half of 2020 was mainly for social spending (56%, 40 cents of every dollar spent is for health care and education). “We are guaranteeing resources for social spending, public investment, and the fundamental resources for health as defined by President Daniel Ortega. As of July 7, 55% of the 2020 budget had been executed and there is an acceleration in health spending. (Radiolaprimerisima, 7/7/20)

Extension of Deadline for Political Parties to Obtain Legal Status
The Supreme Electoral Council extended the deadline for groups to obtain legal status as political parties by fulfilling the existing legal requirements until five months before the next elections of national authorities on November 7, 2021 [May 7, 2021]. The resolution was published on July 14 in the official newspaper La Gaceta; the Supreme Electoral Council Secretary of Actions certified the measure dated July 13, 2020. The resolution is issued to safeguard the certainty, legality, independence, impartiality and objectivity of the popular will in the upcoming elections, the resolution stated. (Radiolaprimerisima, 7/14/20)

Social Advances in Honor of the 41st Anniversary
This week, in celebration of the 41st anniversary of the Sandinista Popular Revolution, the Government is inaugurating schools, fire units, police stations and women’s police stations throughout the country. The first 71 homes will be delivered to families relocated by the expansion of the Juan Pablo II major east-west beltway through Managua. 250 military personnel are disinfecting markets and other public places against Covid-19. Vice President Murillo noted that 191 schools now have access to the Internet. Women’s Police Stations are being relaunched in Bilwi and will serve 60,000 women in the Northern Caribbean Autonomous Region. A new police station will open in La Conquista, Carazo, named for Inspector Faber Antonio López Vivas who was murdered by the US-funded opposition on July 8, 2018. (19Digital, 7/14/20)

Nicaragua Network Sends Greetings to Sandinista Front
The Board and Staff of the Alliance for Global Justice (of which the Nicaragua Network is the founding project) sent the following greeting to the FSLN on the occasion of the 41st anniversary of the Sandinista Revolution:

To our Brothers and Sisters of the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional:

Please accept our solidarity greetings on the 41st anniversary of the Triumph of Sandinista Revolution.

The Nicaragua Network (a project of the Alliance for Global Justice) is proud to have worked for so many years to support the Sandinista Revolution with campaigns in solidarity with farmers and workers, with solid information, and with efforts to change the harmful policies of the US government.

We salute the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional for their steadfast attention to education, health care, and economic development for every Nicaraguan.

We salute the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional for their steadfast support for other countries and political organizations that continue to fight against repressive governments and for democracy throughout Latin America and the world”

We salute the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional for its success in defeating the reactionary forces that attempted a coup to overthrow Nicaragua’s democratically elected government between April and July 2018.

The Nicaragua Network looks forward to working in solidarity with the Frente Sandinista de Liberación Nacional in the years and decades to come.

Adopted by the Board/Staff Collective of the Alliance for Global Justice at its monthly meeting on the 8th day of July of the year 2020.

New Oncological Center
Vice President Rosario Murillo announced that the Oncological Center for Chemotherapy and Palliative Care will be inaugurated in the next few days, “where teams of doctors specialized in pain management will be available; psychologists, physiotherapists, nutritionists, specialists in natural medicine will accompany patients who come to receive their chemotherapy at this center which will have a capacity to care for 100 patients simultaneously in addition to providing space and accommodation for the families.” (Informe Pastran, 7/15/20)

Many People Recuperated from Covid-19
The government weekly report that takes into account July 7 to 13 it indicates there are now 2282 people who have recuperated from COVID-19 in Nicaragua. The report stated that there have been 2682 total registered cases of the disease and there are 301 people who are currently fighting the virus. Eight people last week died bringing total deaths in Nicaragua to 99. (Juventud Presidente, 7/14/20)

Russia donates 5,000 tests for Covid-19
A total of 5,000 tests to diagnose Covid-19 were received July 13 thanks to a donation made by Russia of 30,000 tests for the Central American region. Vinicio Cerezo, Secretary General of SICA expressed his gratitude to the Russian Federation for the support it has been providing to the region in the context of the global Covid-19 pandemic. “We are grateful for the solidarity of the Russian Federation in donating these tests for the region, even though their production is relatively recent and they are covering domestic demand. I am grateful … because it is becoming increasingly difficult to obtain them,” said Cerezo. (Radiolaprimerisima, 7/13/20)

Teacher Training and TV Classes for Students
The Education Ministry (MINED) is providing training to 50,000 teachers to update their pedagogical strategies for the second half of 2020. “We will also continue working on Covid prevention from the schools; here even pre-school children know how to wash their hands properly”, said Miriam Raudez, Minister of Education. Currently teleclasses are provided on two TV stations and various radio stations for kindergarten through sixth grade. Seventh to eleventh graders receive class instructions and materials online. The majority of Nicaragua’s parks and town squares enjoy free wifi. “Now parents are more involved in their children’s classes, and that’s important because it guarantees not only good learning but also the integral development of the students from their homes,” explained primary school teacher Marisol Rosales. More than 1.2 million students will return to the classroom on July 21. (Radiolaprimerisima, 7/14/20)

Report on Exports in the First Six Months of 2020
The report of the Center for Export Procedures (CETREX) indicated that in the first half of 2020 exports reached US$1.58 billion, with gold and coffee the leading exports with US$346 million in export earnings. The other top export products: beef, $US273 million; raw gold, $US 264.4 million; cane sugar, $US120.2 million; beans, $US69.4 million; peanuts, US$50.6 million; moralique cheese, US$30.5 million; cultivated shrimp, $US26.9 million; raw tobacco, US$25.9 million; fish, $US21.6 million; beverages, spirits and vinegar, US$20.3 million; oils and fats, US$16.9 million; lobsters, $US16.8 million; other seafood products, US$ 15.1 million; mozzarella cheese, US$14.4 million; processed cigars, US$11.2 million; processed coffee, US$10.1 million. In the first six months of 2020, US$703.5 million in products were exported to the United States and to Central America US$ 330 million. (Informe Pastran, 7/15/20)